Acumen Blog

Sanergy takes a systems-based approach to solving the sanitation crisis. This includes converting human waste into organic fertilizer.

Innovative Models of Philanthropy & Human Capital Investment Open Pathways to Social Impact

Yasmina Zaidman is the Director of Communications and Strategic Partnerships at Acumen. Below, she discusses three key issues driving growth interest in the social enterprise and impact investing. This post originally appeared on The New Global Citizen

A little less than a year ago, I was in Nairobi hosting a meeting between Acumen’s social enterprises and a group of global corporations interested in engaging more closely with local social entrepreneurs who were meeting for the first time. I had arranged for them to visit one of our portfolio companies, and I picked Sanergy, a company at a relatively early stage, working in Mukuru, one of the largest slums in Nairobi, that provides access to badly needed sanitation services. Sanergy both showcased Acumen’s work and offered the visiting corporate representatives a clearer view of the potential impact of a social enterprise, especially in a market like Kenya.

As we all settled into Sanergy’s conference room, it dawned on me exactly what was about to happen. I was preparing to accompany a group of corporate leaders on a tour of a facility that collects human waste to make organic fertilizer. I had quite possibly lost my mind. I started to doubt that the senior corporate representatives, including a CEO and a foundation head, would share my enthusiasm for Sanergy’s work when it involved walking past mountains of human waste, waving away flies, and learning the intricate mechanics of a dry toilet.

What happened next is what we call an “aha moment.” Each of our visitors showed incredible openness, respect, and sheer curiosity for the work at hand, eager to be challenged and to expand their horizons. Since that day, I promised never to underestimate my corporate colleagues again, and I have seen how eager so many in the corporate world are to challenge themselves by not just stepping up, but leaping outside their comfort zones.

Investing for Sustainability, Scale, and Innovation

This explains the growing interest from the corporate world in impact investing and social enterprise, two emerging sectors that hold tremendous promise for identifying and scaling solutions to major social challenges. Impact investing has grown tremendously as an approach to solve social issues since Acumen helped create the sector ten years ago. This approach involves using finance to invest in enterprises that have social impact as a major business driver, in addition to profitability goals.

Three key issues drive the growing interest in this sector:

First, enterprise must be financially sustainable. The social impact community has grown weary of financing time-bound projects rather than sustainable outcomes, and the drive to find permanent solutions that are not dependent on grants is greater than ever. An enterprise that can generate sufficient revenue can escape this reliance on charity.

Sanergy takes a systems-based approach to solving the sanitation crisis. This includes converting human waste into organic fertilizer.

Sanergy takes a systems-based approach to solving the sanitation crisis. This includes converting human waste into organic fertilizer.

Second, the scale of the solution needs to match the scale of the problem, but many non-profits struggle to achieve scale if they rely exclusively on piecemeal grants. Social enterprises have the potential to scale if they can secure the early-stage risk-tolerant capital they need, prove their business model, and ultimately attract commercial investment.

Lastly, enterprises that can grow and last are insufficient. What makes social enterprise truly exciting is the third piece: innovation. Appropriately directed and supported, social enterprise can develop, pilot, and scale new ideas that have the potential to change entire systems and revolutionize how a good or service is provided to those in need.

The social entrepreneur brings something unique to a social challenge or market failure: iteration, risk-tolerance, and a staunch willingness to forge new ground. Sanergy, for example, dreamt up a new service model for sanitation that brings cleanliness, safety, and dignity to the process. Not only do they increase incomes through a toilet micro-franchise model, but they also convert the human waste to create organic fertilizer. With innovations like this, it’s no wonder that people are taking notice.

Bridging the Pioneer Gap

Yet, the reality is many innovators still struggle to achieve sustainability and scale.  Experience demonstrates that these struggles result from two primary drivers: 1) a lack of philanthropy to support early-stage impact investment and 2) a lack of technical assistance and expertise in business management.

Through research led by the Monitor Inclusive Markets group, “From Blueprint to Scale: The Case for Philanthropy in Impact Investing,” Acumen discovered that impact funds are clustering around larger-scale investments and quicker market returns as opposed to earlier-stage innovations, like Sanergy, that will take longer to reach profitability. In fact, only six out of 84 funds investing in Africa offer early-stage capital.

bridging

Only six out of 84 funds investing in Africa offer early-stage capital to social enterprises like Sanergy.

Acumen calls this gap in capital for early-stage social enterprises the Pioneer Gap, and it is one Acumen and its robust network seek to bridge. By investing patient capital that converts philanthropy into long-term debt and equity investments, Acumen has focused on supporting early-stage social enterprises with the potential for social impact, financial viability, and breakthrough innovation. Indeed, many new organizations have already crossed this Pioneer Gap, accessing grant funding in the earliest stage and refining their model with grant-backed investments from organizations like Acumen until they attract other impact investors and ultimately commercial investments. To date, Acumen has invested $87 million in 81 companies that have attracted an additional $500 million in capital following Acumen’s initial investment.

What’s more, the promise of social enterprise has begun to deliver impact. Nine of Acumen’s portfolio companies are currently impacting over 1 million lives each, and the Acumen portfolio has touched over 120 million lives.

Crossing the Knowledge Frontier

At the same time, a number of companies have fallen far short of their goals, highlighting the second main obstacle facing social enterprises. Many not only lack access to long-term patient capital, but also to knowledge, resources, and expertise. Emerging enterprises need access to business expertise above all else, from financial management to marketing, talent management to strategic planning. So how can promising social enterprises access the business and technical expertise they need to scale? To address this, a natural opportunity to collaborate is emerging between leading corporations and the social enterprise space, specifically focused on the exchange of knowledge, and the infusion of human capital alongside social impact and profit-driven investments.

Social enterprises can benefit tremendously from the expertise, technologies, and networks embedded within leading corporations. But it’s not just social enterprises that stand to benefit; corporations increasingly understand that their business depends on the local knowledge of social entrepreneurs, whose commitment to sustainable development will pave the way for their own business streams in those markets.

This past May, with support from our partner The Dow Chemical Company, Acumen brought these two unlikely but complementary partners together at the first Technical Assistance Summit in Nairobi. The meeting, which sought to catalyze collaboration, led to targeted technical assistance and new relationships between the participating social enterprises and the corporate community. It was a first step, but a critical one, that will enable Acumen to expand the role of corporations supporting social entrepreneurs.

Enabling impact investing and social enterprise to reach their full potential will require both greater strategic early-stage philanthropy and human capital investment. As the value of collaboration between emerging social enterprises and large corporations becomes clearer, how these two types of organizations partner must be further explored and refined. Fortunately, these are questions best answered through experiential learning and reflection. Often the best way to learn is simply by doing.

 

 

Comments

ANNOUNCING A NEW INVESTMENT, FIRST ACCESS

Acumen announces its new investment in First Access, a data analytics company improving access to formal financial services for low-income East African communities. In East Africa, only 22 percent of the population has access to formal financial services with the region’s poor having even less at 10 percent. First Access presents an opportunity to increase the ability of these low-income communities to save, manage risk responsibility, invest in such critical services as education, and ultimately rise out of poverty. [Read More]

ANNOUNCING THE 2015 PAKISTAN FELLOWS

Acumen is proud to announce the selection of our third cohort of Pakistan Fellows. After a competitive application process, we’ve chosen a diverse group of 20 leaders working in provinces across the country. This year’s Fellows are fighting poverty and changing lives across Pakistan through unique initiatives that range from advocating for vulnerable prisoners’ rights, to creating solutions to address low-quality education, to developing branchless banking channels for low-income customers, and more. Read more about each Fellow and their inspiring work below. [Read More]

Lean Data Goes Deeper

One of the most interesting questions we’re grappling with right now on the Impact team at Acumen is how to develop a more robust, rigorous, and transparent form of quantifying the social value our companies create. While I don’t believe we will ever fully understand all the social value created – and while there will always be room for debate and interpretation – I do think today we have the tools to get a lot closer to customers and hear how they value products. [Read More]

ANNOUNCING THE 2015 INDIA FELLOWS

Acumen is proud to announce the selection of our second cohort of India Fellows. After a competitive application process, we’ve chosen a diverse group of 20 leaders working in 13 states. This year’s Fellows are fighting poverty and changing lives across India through unique initiatives that range from providing affordable menstrual hygiene products to marginalized women, to making quality education available to children in conflict zones, to designing innovative sanitation solutions for the urban poor, and more. Read more about each Fellow and their inspiring work below. [Read More]

ACUMEN NAMED ONE OF WORLD’S TOP 10 MOST INNOVATIVE COMPANIES IN NOT-FOR-PROFIT BY FAST COMPANY

Fast Company today announced its 2015 ranking of the World’s Most Innovative Companies in Not-For-Profit, honoring leading organizations and rising newcomers that exemplify the best in social and philanthropic innovation. Acumen earned the No. 7 spot on the annual list in recognition for its Lean Data Initiative—a project launched in 2014 to find more efficient, cost-effective ways to measure and evaluate social impact. [Read More]

ANNOUNCING THE 2015 EAST AFRICA FELLOWS

Acumen is proud to announce the selection of our fourth cohort of East Africa Fellows. After a competitive application process, we’ve chosen a diverse group of 21 leaders from five different countries in the region: Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Rwanda and, for the first time, Ethiopia. This year’s Fellows are fighting poverty and changing lives across East Africa through unique initiatives that range from providing much-needed ambulance services to helping make hygienic sanitation more accessible and affordable to empowering young women to start viable agro-enterprises and more. Read more about each Fellow and their inspiring work below. [Read More]

We Are Each Other’s Destiny

To reflect on the life of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. is to consider deeply our human interconnectedness and the world we want to build. Each year on this day, I re-read his extraordinary, elegiac “Letter from Birmingham Jail” to remember his commitment to human equality and the price he paid. I read it to remind myself of the power of idealism grounded in pragmatism. I read it to renew my belief in our individual and collective abilities to help bend the moral arc ever more toward justice. [Read More]

Let’s Work Together

Acumen has offices in New York, Mumbai, Karachi, Bogota, Nairobi and Accra. Last August, Avinash Mishra, a Senior Portfolio Associate in the India office, and Keya Madhvani, the Internal Communications Associate in the New York office, were nominated to attend the One Young World Summit in Dublin. Below, they share lessons learned at the summit.  [Read More]